Opening Night | Lyric Theatre, Sydney | 19 November 2026
By Damien Barrett @_helloshoppers
There is no denying that Neil Diamond has a back catalogue most musical theatre producers would give their right arm for. From Sweet Caroline to Cracklin’ Rosie, Song Sung Blue and I Am… I Said, the songs are familiar, the audience knows the words, and there is an almost irresistible urge to sing along. So, on paper, A Beautiful Noise has all the ingredients for a crowd-pleasing night at the theatre. And for the most part, it delivers.
Telling the story of Diamond’s life through two versions of the man, the production moves between Neil Then and Neil Now, exploring the highs of international superstardom and the more complicated personal journey behind the music.
Terence Crawford as Neil Now is an absolute standout. He captures Diamond beautifully, especially the vulnerability of a man reflecting on his life, his achievements, and, perhaps most poignantly, the reality of making peace with a world where he can no longer perform. His portrayal has a genuine emotional connection, and he gives the role a warmth and depth that anchors the production.
Then there is the top-notch international talent of Will Swenson as Neil Then. Swenson brings enormous presence and energy to the role, delivering the swagger, ambition and unmistakable charisma of a young Neil Diamond. Together, Crawford and Swenson provide two very different but equally compelling interpretations of the man.
However, if one performer deserves a little extra attention, it is Ashleigh Rubenach. Absolutely mesmerising on stage, she has that rare ability to command an audience without trying. She literally lights up the stage, and I found myself wanting more of her every time she appeared. Quite frankly, she deserves a big star vehicle with her name above the title. Producers, take note!
The production falters in its second act. The tone becomes considerably darker and, at times, rather gloomy. While I appreciate that Diamond’s life wasn’t all sunshine, sold-out concerts, and Sweet Caroline singalongs, the shift in mood is pronounced and takes some of the evening’s momentum.
The choreography is another curious element. There are moments where it feels distinctly odd, occasionally jarring and not entirely in keeping with the music or the storytelling. Given the extraordinary catalogue of songs available, I was expecting something a little more fluid and exciting. At times, the movement seems to work against the music rather than enhance it.
And it does raise a bigger question about musical theatre at the moment. We seem to be seeing an awful lot of jukebox and biographical musicals: Beautiful, Jersey Boys and now A Beautiful Noise, to name just a few. Don’t get me wrong, I love a familiar tune as much as the next theatre-goer, but are these really the only productions that producers feel confident will make money and sell tickets these days? Is the industry becoming too reliant on established musical catalogues and recognisable names, rather than taking a punt on something new and original?
There is certainly an audience for these productions, and Neil Diamond’s music is proof that a great song never really dates. But I would love to see a little more creative risk-taking alongside the jukebox favourites.
For all you Barbra-holics out there (you know who you are), we do get one of my favourite Neil Diamond songs, You Don’t Bring Me Flowers, heart-breakingly sung by Swenson and Rubenach as the relationship of their two characters breaks down and ultimately ends.
Ultimately, A Beautiful Noise is an enjoyable evening, elevated considerably by two terrific leading performances and a particularly dazzling Ashleigh Rubenach. It has moments of musical magic, even if the second act and some staging choices keep it from being a completely seamless experience.
And really, when the opening notes of Sweet Caroline ring out, it is almost impossible not to join in. BA BA BA!
A Beautiful Noise – The Neil Diamond Musical with book by Anthony McCarten and music and lyrics by Neil Diamond plays at Sydney’s Lyric Theatre through 14 February 2027












In his past lives, Damien was a drag queen and musical theatre actor. He made his stage debut as a fat cow in a school production of Joseph in 1984. He holds a BA with a major in drama from the University of Newcastle. He is completely obsessed with musical theatre – especially Broadway divas.
Since relocating to Sydney at the beginning of 2024, he attends every musical he can get to and lives with his partner and grumpy 12-year-old poodle.
His claim to fame is that he once met Patti Lupone in New York and she was nice to him.

